After recently stepping up, along with Sen. Russ Feingold (D-WI), to block the nomination to the FEC of insidious GOP “voter fraud” zealot Hans Von Spakovsky, Illinois’ Democratic Senator and Presidential Candidate Barack Obama is calling for the head of the Voting Rights Section chief of the DoJ’s Civil Rights Division.
In a letter sent today (posted in full at end of this article) to Acting Attorney General, Peter D. Keisler, Obama has requested that John Tanner be sent packing following objectionable comments he made two weeks ago in Los Angeles at the National Latino Congresso.
The remarks by Tanner, video-taped and first reported by The BRAD BLOG, were meant in support of his decision to allow a Photo ID restriction at polling places in Georgia, over the recommendation of four out of five of the career attorneys in the Civil Rights unit. The law would later be found unconstitutional by two federal judges, one of whom declared the practice to be a “Jim Crow-era poll tax”.
Tanner told audience members during the panel on October 5th, that while it was a “shame” that the elderly would, in fact, be disenfranchised by the law he approved on behalf of the DoJ, minorities would have less to worry about because, as he told the stunned room, “Our society is such that minorities don’t become elderly the way white people do. They die first.”
Former colleagues of Tanner went on to characterize his comments as “false”, “ludicrous” and “cherry-picked” from existing data.
In his letter today, Obama said, “Such comments are patently erroneous, offensive, and dangerous, and they are especially troubling coming from the federal official charged with protecting voting rights in this country.”
As we reported several days ago, Tanner is scheduled to testify on this and related matters to a sub-commitee of the House Judiciary Committee on October 30th. The committee has asked The BRAD BLOG for a copy of the entire session with Tanner, as video-taped by our own Alan Breslauer. We have complied with their request.
In breaking the news of Obama’s letter this morning, TPM Muckraker’s Paul Kiel noted the irony that during his appearance before the Judiciary Committee, Tanner will “get to explain personally to its 78 year-old African-American chairman [John Conyers] that minorities don’t ‘become elderly.'”
“Through his inexcusable comments,” Obama writes in today’s letter, “Mr. Tanner has clearly demonstrated that he possesses neither the character nor the judgment to be heading the Voting Rights Section. For that reason, I respectfully request that you remove him from his position.”
Since the 2004 election, Republican officials and operatives have been attempting to enact such Photo ID laws at polling places across the country, despite some 10 to 30 million, largely Democratic and minority voters, who do not have such ID’s and would be disenfranchised by such laws. Millions of dollars have been spent to support the unevidenced idea of Democratic “voter fraud” by phony GOP front groups such as the “non-partisan” ACVR, created by Bush/Cheney ’04’s national general counsel Mark F. “Thor” Hearne and RNC Communications Director, Jim Dyke. Hearne is now laying low since shutting down the ACVR in the wake of calls for phony “voter fraud” prosecutions being found at the center of the U.S. Attorney Purge scandal. Dyke, who parlayed his “non-partisan” ACVR gig into work for Dick Cheney, is now Communications Director for the Rudy Giuliani campaign.
Continuing the false GOP meme of Democratic “voter fraud”, The BRAD BLOG recently noted unsupported claims of undocumented immigrants being “rounded up, herded into the polls [and] voting illegally” in California as charged by Golden State Rep. Duncan Hunter during a recent Republican Presidential Debate. Both Hunter’s campaign and Congressional offices subsequently failed to respond to BRAD BLOG requests to back up with the claim with details or evidence.
During it’s current session, the Supreme Court of the United States is scheduled to review the constitutionality of a similar Photo ID law enacted in the state of Indiana.
UPDATE: AP picks up the story, quotes DoJ as saying Tanner’s comments were “grossly misconstrued”, fails to credit BRAD BLOG for breaking original story. Details here…
LATER UPDATE: WaPo again picks up the story, and again, as last time (and unlike AP) credits us appropriately. They also offer yet another DoJ spokesman’s defense of Tanner, while an insider DoJ source gives us an indication of what’s really going on over at DoJ in the wake of all of this. Details here…
The complete letter from Sen. Barack Obama to Acting Attorney General Peter D. Keisler follows below…
The Honorable Peter D. Keisler
Acting Attorney General
Department of Justice
950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20530-0001
Dear Mr. Keisler:
On October 5, 2007, at the National Latino Congreso in Los Angeles, John Tanner, the chief of the voting rights section of the Civil Rights Division, spoke on a panel regarding minority voters. During the course of that discussion, which focused on recent state laws requiring photo identification for voting, Mr. Tanner said that such photo ID requirements disadvantage the elderly “[a]nd that’s a shame.” He explained: “You know, creating problems for elderly persons just is not good under any circumstance.”
However, according to Mr. Tanner, such requirements do not disenfranchise minorities, and in fact, they actually benefit minorities. He said: “Our society is such that minorities don’t become elderly the way white people do; they die first. There are inequities in health care. There are a variety of inequities in this country. And so anything that disproportionately impacts the elderly has the opposite impact on minorities; just the math is such as that.”
Such comments are patently erroneous, offensive, and dangerous, and they are especially troubling coming from the federal official charged with protecting voting rights in this country. Mr. Tanner has already demonstrated questionable judgment in overruling the decision of Justice Department lawyers that the Georgia photo ID requirement would disproportionately discriminate against African Americans. For Mr. Tanner to now suggest, in an effort to defend his erroneous decision, that photo identification are not necessary for minority voters because “they die first” shows just how far the Justice Department has fallen. This is a disgrace and yet another reason why the next Attorney General must demonstrate a strong commitment to civil rights.
But, until the next Attorney General is confirmed, you are in charge of the Department, and you are in charge of ensuring that our laws are enforced and that the civil rights of all Americans are protected. Through his inexcusable comments, Mr. Tanner has clearly demonstrated that he possesses neither the character nor the judgment to be heading the Voting Rights Section. For that reason, I respectfully request that you remove him from his position.
Sincerely,
Barack Obama
United States Senator
…OR…”Voting White’s Cheat”…
Actually, we call it the “Civil Whites Division.” Have for years.
Brad, you were channeling CRT employees.
Well, go figure IceJustIce!
Please let the boys know I’m available for the job once they dump Tanner. (That is, as long as PFAW doesn’t ask me to fill Ralph Neas’ job or LA County doesn’t call upon me to fill Registrar Conny McCormack’s job first!)
😉
Racist? I dont know you tell me. What I read was that anything that heavily disfavors the elderly…will benefit minorities. That is to say only young minorities because they don’t live to be old. As a DOJ official I’m sure he’s read more than one paper by an analyst on whose going to jail, jail deaths, and homicide rates. I expect him to be an expert on who makes it into adult hood. Healthcare-wise. As of 2001 statistics, mortality rates for African-American women are higher than any other racial/ethnic group for nearly every major cause of death including heart disease, lung cancer, cerebrovascular disease, breast cancer, and chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases. Death rates from cancer have been declining among both African American men and women, according to Cancer Facts & Figures for African Americans 2007-2008. Yet the cancer death rate is still 35% higher for African American men compared to white men and 18% higher in African American women compared to white women. In fact, African Americans have the highest death rate and shortest survival rate of any other racial or ethnic group for most cancers, the report says. You want this man to be president. He won’t even take the time to study the facts and figures before he calls for someone being fired. Everything the man said was true. BTW, I don’t think highlighting one person even if they are 78 who is a senior to seemingly back up error of Tanner’s ways makes much of a difference when you look at the real numbers. And why is it when a white person says something its racist, but when a minority says it…its philosophical?
imagine the SOCIAL CONSEQUENCE IF the KKK took a swing @ Obama or WE *were simply made to believe* someone *might*
you know, the way the US Congress believed there would be a Summer attack
or continues to reel under the Anthrax Killer
if you thought 9/11 sent Americans shrieking over the Brink
what would happen if the REAL Bushevik backers’ desire was further reductions in freedoms & rights? what if Bush’s backers want something sinister?
what if the point isn’t POLITICAL PARTIES, but merely Security & Social Controls?
===
=
maybe the ELECTION & primaries is more about the Republicans picking the MOST BELIEVABLE Republican ‘win’-& as wonderful as ANY Democrat might be
there is STILL ELECTION FRAUD.
Arrive with FIVE
& bring your vid’camera!
be aware
maybe there is more to this problem than simply WINNING back election integrity
in that case… the Bushevik BACKERS would be permanently in the position to do *whatever they want*… without bothering with meddlesome Democracy & political parties, right?
=
now… think about it…
West’s deadly N-secrets for sale
Sibel Edmonds, a 37-year-old former Turkish language translator for the FBI, who had listened into hundreds of sensitive intercepted conversations…
===
BlueBerry Pick’n
ThisCanadian
“We, two, form a Multitude” ~ Ovid
Silent Freedom is Freedom Silenced”