ES&S Op-Scans ‘Yielding Different Results Each Time Same Ballots Run Through Machines’ in MI County

Failure Discovered During Pre-Election Testing on Systems Used Widely Throughout U.S.; Company Failed to Perform Maintenance

Letter Sent from County to Federal Officials Last Week; Has EAC Notified Other Jurisdictions as Per Their Federal Mandate?...

Share article:

Guest Blogged by John Gideon of VotersUnite.org

The U.S. Election Assistance Commission (EAC) received this letter [PDF] well over a week ago from Oakland County, MI, concerning ES&S precinct-based optical-scan systems that “yielded different results each time” the “same ballots were run through the same machines”…

The issue is this – four of our communities or eight percent – reported inconsistent vote totals during their logic and accuracy testing with the ES&S machines. The same ballots, run through the same machines, yielded different results each time.

ES&S determined that the primary issue was dust and debris build-up on the sensors inside the M-100.

Unfortunately, they [local clerks] are prohibited from performing any maintenance/cleaning on the machines as it voids the warranties. ES&S has not performed any preventative maintenance under the state contract, since the machines were delivered three years ago.

This problem, discovered during pre-election “Logic & Accuracy” testing of the systems, would hardly be the first time that ES&S has failed to deliver on maintenance contracts, adversely affecting voters and election results in the bargain. We saw many similar problems during the 2006 primary election cycle. These precinct-based scanners are used throughout the nation, as ES&S is the nation’s largest distributor of voting systems in the U.S.

The EAC received this letter a week ago, and we’re trying to learn when it was finally posted to their website. But, more importantly, as they have a mandate via the Help America Vote Act (HAVA) of 2002 to serve as a “clearinghouse” for such voting system problems, has the EAC sent a warning about this issue to any other jurisdictions where the same equipment or company is used?

Share article:

Reader Comments on

ES&S Op-Scans ‘Yielding Different Results Each Time Same Ballots Run Through Machines’ in MI County

9 Comments

(Comments are now closed.)


9 Responses

  1. 1)
    Lora said on 11/3/2008 @ 4:40pm PT: [Permalink]

    What a great letter! But why — oh WHY — didn’t she request permission to perform a hand-counted audit instead of asking to use a recently cleaned machine???!!! *smacks forehead in exasperation*

  2. 3)
    Kira said on 11/3/2008 @ 4:59pm PT: [Permalink]

    Thank You HAVA. [Hinder American Voters Act]

    What will be the straw that breaks the camel’s back? Arrgghh!!!!!

  3. 4)
    Soul Rebel said on 11/3/2008 @ 5:59pm PT: [Permalink]

    This whole issue with the maintenance contracts is yet another scam being pulled off by the voting machine companies. The same crap happened in New Mexico, with ES&S machines – many counties had qualified techs to service them but ES&S refused to honor their qualifications and would only allow ES&S certified employees to service the machines. ES&S sucks. Blows. Whatever. What can we do to put these bastards out of business.

    Besides electing competent Secretaries of State and County Clerks, that is?

  4. 5)
    SillyGit said on 11/3/2008 @ 12:22am PT: [Permalink]

    SoulRebel said:

    What can we do to put these bastards out of business.

    Nuke them from orbit. It’s the only way to be sure.

  5. 6)
    Margaret Sullivan said on 11/3/2008 @ 12:40am PT: [Permalink]

    This problem with the ES&S voting machines in Oakland County, Michigan is so discouraging! I live and vote in Oakland County.

    I would be very interested to know what has been done to correct the problem before 11/4.

    Please post any new information regarding whether the faulty machines have been taken out of service,

    Thank you!

  6. 7)
    Savantster said on 11/4/2008 @ 9:27am PT: [Permalink]

    Since they can’t out right steal this election, they are content to let random chance decide!

    Only in America can so many people not care if their vote is counted, they just figure being able to show up and cast a vote is good enough. Why are these people so stupid as to not understand that casting a vote is only 1/2 of the process? ACCURATELY COUNTING the vote is the other important part.

    We’re so screwed..

  7. 8)
    Lottakatz said on 11/4/2008 @ 9:46am PT: [Permalink]

    SillyGit :
    “Nuke them from orbit. It’s the only way to be sure.”

    😉 I saw that movie this morning about 1:00 AM (for about the 100th time) and that line just struck me as the perfect (metaphorical) response to the whole voting machine problem. (I need to leave to vote in about 30 minutes, I’ve been having serious voting anxiety for the last several days.)
    We just need to end the charade. An Executive Order repealing HAVA in the first 100 days would be a good start. “Game over man, game over!”

(Comments are now closed.)


BB SIDEBAR NOTICE

Thanks to you, The BRAD BLOG has been trouble-making and muckraking for … 22 YEARS!!!

Please help The BRAD BLOG, BradCast and Green News Report remain independent and 100% reader and listener supported in our 23rd YEAR!!!

ONE TIME
any amount...

MONTHLY
any amount...

OR VIA SNAIL MAIL
Make check out to...
Brad Friedman / BRAD BLOG
7095 Hollywood Blvd., #594
Los Angeles, CA 90028

RECENT POSTS

Sunday ‘Have You Considered Treason?’ Toons

THIS WEEK: The Unstoppable Steal ... The Colbert Canary ... The Paxton Primer ...

Republicans Are Revolting: ‘BradCast’ 5/21/2026

Guests: Heather Digby Parton of Salon, 'Driftglass' of 'Pro Left Podcast' on the primaries, the ballroom, the slush fund, the wars, the media, Stephen Colbert, and much more...

‘Green News Report’ – May 21, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

Primary Results from Six States and Trump’s $1.8 Billion Taxpayer-Funded Grift Machine: ‘BradCast’ 5/20/2026

Results and context from AL, GA, ID, KY, OR, PA; Also: Jan. 6 U.S. Capitol cops file suit to shutdown Trump's 'insurrectionist slush fund'...

NAACP Calls for Voting Rights Boycott of College Sports at Southern Schools: ‘BradCast’ 5/19/2026

Also: We endorse Trump's endorsement in TX GOP U.S. Senate runoff!; DOJ adds MORE corruption to Trump's already 'most corrupt' agreement in U.S. history...

‘Green News Report’ – May 19, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

‘The Most Corrupt Thing in ALL of American History’: Trump’s $1.8 Billion DOJ-Facilitated Taxpayer Heist: ‘BradCast’ 5/18/2026

Guest: Robert Weissman of Public Citizen; Also: Election results from LA; Mass voting rights protest in AL; More...

Sunday ‘All Over the Map’ Toons

THIS WEEK: South Rising Again ... T in China ... Strait Outta Hormuz ...

More GOP Vote Rigging Underway. Hey, Maryland Dems! Time to Get Crackin’!: ‘BradCast’ 5/14/2026

Also: GA GOP rigs Atlanta D.A. elections; MT's new voter suppression law nixed by state court; Much more...

‘Green News Report’ – May 14, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen...

Do Dems Have the Courage Required to Restore and Reform American Democracy? (Do You?): ‘BradCast’ 5/13/2026

Guest: Kate Riga of Talking Points Memo; Also: SC Senate leader blocks U.S. House gerrymandering; Primary results from WV, NE...

Offshore Oil Rig Fire in SoCal a Preview of Trump’s NEXT Huge Failure: ‘BradCast’ 5/12/2026

Guest: Brady Bradshaw of Center for Biological Diversity; Also: Inflation spiked to 3-year high in April; Dems still favored to win House, despite GOP map rigging...

‘Green News Report’ – May 12, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen...

Virginia Supremes Void Special Election on Redistricting Referendum in Huge Gift to Vote Rigging GOP: ‘BradCast’ 5/11/2026

Voting rights disappearing, Jim Crow returning before our eyes in GOP-controlled state after state; Callers ring in...

Sunday ‘Redlining Democracy’ Toons

THIS WEEK: The Voting Whites Act ... Iran and Iran We Go ... Happy Mother's Day! ...

About Brad Friedman...

Brad is an independent investigative journalist, blogger and broadcaster. Full Bio & Testimonials… Media Appearance Archive… Articles & Editorials Elsewhere… Contact…

He has contributed chapters to these books…
…And is featured in these documentary films…

BRAD BLOG ON THE AIR!

THE BRADCAST on KPFK/Pacifica Radio Network (90.7FM Los Angeles, 98.7FM Santa Barbara, 93.7FM N. San Diego and nationally syndicated, Monday-Thursday, on many other affiliate stations! ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneIn | Apple Podcasts/iTunes | iHeart | Amazon Music
GREEN NEWS REPORT, nationally syndicated, with new episodes on Tuesday and Thursday. ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneIn | Apple Podcasts/iTunes | iHeart | Amazon Music
Media Appearance Archives…

AD CONTENT

ADDITIONAL STUFF

Brad Friedman/
The BRAD BLOG Named...

Buzz Flash's 'Wings of Justice' Honoree
Project Censored 2010 Award Recipient
The 2008 Weblog Awards