Blogged by Brad Friedman on 5/16/2006 3:00PM  
Train Wreck in Progress as Today's Primary Elections in PA Run Into Big Trouble...
Paper Ballots Being Passed Out, 'We're Dead' Says One Official ... (Who could have forseen such problems?!)


Pennsylvania is having their primary elections today and, as expected, the train wreck is underway. As reported by Philadelphia Daily News, hundreds of machines (in this case, those made by Danaher Guardian) have failed...

BREAKING NEWS: 100 voting machines broken

More than 100 voting machines are reported to be broken across the city, the Daily News has learned.

Apparently, the machines were broken when polls opened this morning --- they keep spitting out the paper tape that keeps the tally of the vote. It is the largest breakdown since we started using the new voting machines.

The broken machines were first reported in the weblog for TheNextMayor.com. Expect more on this story in tomorrow's Daily News.

The local ABC affiliate has more details. Amongst them...

The biggest problems have been at voting locations where multiple failures have been reported.

Ward 12, Division 20 in Germantown is one such location. Judge of Elections Bernard Bibbs followed the routine startup procedure, but neither machine would activate. In one case, the write-in paper tape just unrolled and then refused to roll back up. In the other case, the machine will only beep and do nothing else.

Bernard Bibbs/Judge of Elections: "We set them up the way they're supposed to be run electronically. They've been shut down all morning.... We're dead."

Similar problems have popped up across the city. Machines by the score have failed to operate. In most places, at least one machine is functioning. In those places where all the machines are down, voters can request a paper ballot.

Edward Schulgen/Deputy City Commissioner: "Give that voter a paper ballot, which is then sent to us after the election. We verify whether or not that person is registered in the right division. If that's correct, then we count that vote."

The number of failures seems to be evenly distributed across the city. It's more voting machine failures than the city has ever had before.

More from TheNextMayor.com...

This from an e-mail from a NextMayor friend...

"I voted before leaving for DC this morning and was told before voting that the write-in function on my machine was not working because the paper roll inside would not come up. Because I wanted to write in a candidate, I therefore had to fill out a provisional ballot, which may or may not be counted in the end.

I later heard from my judge of elections that this problem was happening AT EVERY VOTING MACHINE IN THE CITY."

LATE UPDATE: 100's of machines also failed in Pittsburgh across the state in Allegheny County! Details...

Buzz this story! C2NN: Submit it!


READER COMMENTS ON
"BREAKING: HUNDREDS OF VOTING MACHINES BREAK DOWN IN PHILLY!"
(28 Responses so far...)

COMMENT #1 [Permalink]
... Susan said on 5/16/2006 @ 3:16 pm PT...


Geez. Bet we won't even see a glimmer of this in the MSM. After all, it's just a glitch.


COMMENT #2 [Permalink]
... NC Voter said on 5/16/2006 @ 3:48 pm PT...


It's a miracle!


COMMENT #3 [Permalink]
... Bernadette Bay O'Shaughnessey said on 5/16/2006 @ 5:30 pm PT...


WOW! Got to hand it to those Republicans: with no paper trails allowed and no exit polls allowed, they have succeeded in rigging yet ANOTHER election! In the most crooked wards of Chicago, you never saw such success at vote-rigging! Wonder how long, now, until King George declares martial law and we don't vote at all!


COMMENT #4 [Permalink]
... Al F said on 5/16/2006 @ 5:33 pm PT...


In my opinion the electronic voting machines were created to allow corrupeted criminal politicians to steal votes and steal the election so as to push their NWO agenda upon the people.

The NEOCON's and all their cronies are behind this and they must be stopped!!!...

Al F


COMMENT #5 [Permalink]
... Rusty said on 5/16/2006 @ 5:54 pm PT...


Will there be a hand cout of votes or will they just give it to the damm repugs again??!! IF all of you out there let this happen any where then we are all screwed. Maybe it is time to rethink our options with the current regime. Damm it America wake up and stop the neo-con-death-cult before it is to late for us to even think for our-selfs.
Resident chuckle-nuts and his cronies will kill us all if he is not stopped.
FIRE THE LIARS!!!!!!!!!!!!
Support our troops by not lying to them.
Plus the only thing that he has done good for America, is by putting our troops on the mexican border. But they should be armed while they are there.
Protect America first!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FIRE the LIARS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

:plain:http://www.bradblog.com/Images/emoticons/plain.gif
plain jane


COMMENT #6 [Permalink]
... Roger said on 5/16/2006 @ 7:35 pm PT...


Ever think that the installers of these machines know what's going on and did this on purpose? Or is that too much?


COMMENT #7 [Permalink]
... peggy said on 5/16/2006 @ 7:52 pm PT...


This fiasco will be the excuse the voting machine companies and their GOP facilitators need to deny voters a paper trail. I can hear it now, "we tried to give a paper receipt but you see what happened the machines failed."

We need to go back to paper ballots counted by human beings and available for later review if and when needed.

Isn't it amazing that machine errors are almost always documented as favoring the Repugnantcans?


COMMENT #8 [Permalink]
... bigdavefromqueens said on 5/16/2006 @ 8:24 pm PT...


I fear for my country. I want to live in a democracy where the values of our Constitution are protected and where the will of the people is truly represented by having every able bodied adult cast a vote and having that vote count as intended. If we do not live in that country, I fear that millions of Americans will one day take to the streets and make sure that the neocons are not in office.


COMMENT #9 [Permalink]
... Lionel Artom-Ginzburg said on 5/16/2006 @ 8:30 pm PT...


Write-ins were *not* broken throughout the city. It was machine by machine. I was in five wards today-- the 8th (west CC) was fine, the 5th (east CC) was mostly fine, the 30th (Graduate Hospital) had some problems, and the 2nd (Bella Vista) had some very bad problems, but localized at one or two polling places. I was told by some committeepeople in the 36th (Gray's Ferry) that the problems were crippling where they happened, but not universal.

The explanation that we (in the Josephs campaign in the 182nd-- basically CC, Bella Vista, and Gray's Ferry) got was that the mechanisms that were installed for the visually impaired to read ballot lines royally screwed up the machines. (We were also told that some of the problems in Fishtown had to do with machines being stored below street level getting wet during the flooding yesterday) It's a pretty believable explanation-- these machines are so primitive, that there's not a whole hell of a lot that could go wrong (and anyone who wanted to hack them would need to be capable of manipulating bits on an EPROM)


COMMENT #10 [Permalink]
... George said on 5/17/2006 @ 1:28 am PT...


wHICH cOMPANY

Diebold, Sequoia or S&SE

tHEY WILLWIN hOUSE AGAIN


COMMENT #11 [Permalink]
... Joyful Alternative said on 5/17/2006 @ 4:51 am PT...


Please, BigDavefromQueens, edit your elegant sentiment. My late husband, in his wheelchair and with one arm paralyzed and barely able to speak, was the most enthusiastic and thoughtful voter I've ever seen.


COMMENT #12 [Permalink]
... Dredd said on 5/17/2006 @ 5:39 am PT...


Lionel Artom-Ginzburg #9

You said "... anyone who wanted to hack them would need to be capable of manipulating bits on an EPROM ..."

If a hacker could get access to write to an EPROM, only a novice would mess with the bits. A competent hacker would just overwrite the entire target area with new code. And if the hacker was topnotch, the CRC would match the original, even tho the code would be different and adverse.


COMMENT #13 [Permalink]
... Bj said on 5/17/2006 @ 5:47 am PT...


These problems with Diebold have been going on for years.. just like most of us (online in blogs) know that a diebold exec told bush's people he'd hand Ohio to Bush in 2004.. well he did.. who even knows about this?

have we ever seen it on cnn or msnbc? i haven't.. and i watch them all the time..

the exec if i recall resigned a yr or 2 later over other business scandals..

welcome to the world of republican run corrupt government :(

oh by the way as i posted on my blog for today, home forclosures are at record highs...


COMMENT #14 [Permalink]
... Rumple Stiltskin said on 5/17/2006 @ 6:00 am PT...


Golly. Cash registers and ATMs across the land have spit out paper receipts without a hitch for many years. Somehow, we are supposed to believe that the same functionality represents an insurmountable challenge when it comes to voting machines. This, in the 21st Century. I feel like I'm living inside an episode of "The Flintstones."


COMMENT #15 [Permalink]
... Lionel Artom-Ginzburg said on 5/17/2006 @ 6:59 am PT...


If a hacker could get access to write to an EPROM, only a novice would mess with the bits. A competent hacker would just overwrite the entire target area with new code. And if the hacker was topnotch, the CRC would match the original, even tho the code would be different and adverse.

Agreed. I wasn't being precise. But what I meant is that these machines are 1980 technology-- it's not as simple as hacking in from an unprotected port or altering things from Windows, like Diebold. (The Philadelphia machines were not made by Diebold or ESS, incidentally) The actual data is stored in a cartridge about the size of an old Atari 2600 cartridge.

(I should also point out that the candidate I was working for yesterday, Rep. Josephs, is on record as being in favor of abolishing the machines and going back to paper ballots. )


COMMENT #16 [Permalink]
... lutton said on 5/17/2006 @ 7:51 am PT...


Chris Bowers discusses this in some detail over at mydd.com


COMMENT #17 [Permalink]
... V. Kurt Bellman said on 5/17/2006 @ 10:28 am PT...


Please, take some time to do your homework before spouting off about the Rupugs and any problems in Pennsylvania.

The story in Pennsylvania is that dozens of powerful Republicans lost huge in elections all across PA. Senate President Pro Tempore and Majority Leader were both turned out in relative landslides. A special election in Chester County elected the first Democrat since dirt was invented.

If powerful incumbents and status quo protectors were pulling strings in electronic voting, these events would not have happened.

Take off your ideological blinders and read the news, instead of each others' rants. In Pennsylvania at least electronic voting statewide has pretty badly crippled the Republican power brokers.


COMMENT #18 [Permalink]
... Dredd said on 5/17/2006 @ 10:41 am PT...


Lionel Artom-Ginzburg #15

How are the cartridge units inserted and removed?

What type memory chips are they?

Are EPROMS also on the cartridges?


COMMENT #19 [Permalink]
... banana slug said on 5/17/2006 @ 11:20 am PT...


While I was voting yesterday (South Philly), one machine jammed on me and they switched me to the other, which also didn't work properly. I am all but sure it didn't record my write in votes properly.
Who knows about the rest.
A hell of a mess.


COMMENT #20 [Permalink]
... Larry Bergan said on 5/17/2006 @ 11:39 am PT...


V. Kurt Bellman # 17

That's good news! Looks like the Republicans may be getting concerned that stealing elections might be dangerous to THEIR freedom!


COMMENT #21 [Permalink]
... RecallVotingMachines said on 5/17/2006 @ 1:28 pm PT...


Haven't we been expectng this?? Now's the time to change it and make the entire country aware, not just those who have been paying attention. Demand a receipt for your vote, immediately!! Or do a write-in. PA should re-do the entire election. When I heard PA got votng machines, I could not believe my eyes.


COMMENT #22 [Permalink]
... doubleb said on 5/17/2006 @ 2:42 pm PT...


The bottom line is.... Have the breakdowns happened more in Democratic or Republican voting districts?


COMMENT #23 [Permalink]
... makesenseofit said on 5/17/2006 @ 4:21 pm PT...


I am sure it will be fixed for the next election... but newer machines will be used. Ones that are not tested prior to the election. I bet the other machines used in Florida will be better than those used in Philly.. except maybe for the location of the voting machines themselves...


COMMENT #24 [Permalink]
... V. Kurt Bellman said on 5/17/2006 @ 4:34 pm PT...


Doubleb,

It is not known where the majority of machines broke down and it doesn't matter. It was a closed primary, where Democrats can only vote for Democrats and Republicans can only vote for Republicans, and everyone else can't vote at all.

My county, Berks county, also had Danaher machine issues, and I can tell you they were almost all in heavily Republcan areas, as are the longest lines in November elections.

My experience has been the exact OPPOSITE of Ohio 2004. The system breakdowns always seem to happen in Republican areas.


COMMENT #25 [Permalink]
... As I C It said on 5/17/2006 @ 8:21 pm PT...


Just thinking back to the good ole days when all we had were a few dimpled chads!


COMMENT #26 [Permalink]
... PAcleansweeper said on 5/18/2006 @ 2:03 am PT...


Not even Deibold can stop pissed off masses.The whole country should take lessons.Vote every incumbent out,its the only way to take back our country.We ousted 16 the last count i heard legislators in just primaries.More to follow including Santorum hes dead meat i predict.
http://www.allheadlinene....com/articles/7003609766


COMMENT #27 [Permalink]
... Jake Lake said on 5/18/2006 @ 2:58 pm PT...


It does require cautiously speculative thinking to believe that any recent or future voting can ever be certified - and by whom? Only pen & paper can save us. I can believe that when it looks like republicans are being affected, especially in primaries, I trust there is a underlying motive of distraction.

Each and every partisan politician is expendible. Unlike 'drug users' who are immediately incarcerated, it takes 'our' justice system years to prosecute these special citizens only to hand down light punishment. They suffer no real jail time or even loss of respect for their negligent mis-management or actual crimes committed extending illegal wars or limiting our rights.

If they speak against the status quo they are quickly silenced or worse, like Conyers or Wellstone. But continuing the illusion of terror, stealing, lying and abandoning our Founders' democratic principles makes for a great schedule of lucrative speaking engagements and book deals after a short rest in minimum security detention!


COMMENT #28 [Permalink]
... catbeller said on 5/19/2006 @ 11:24 pm PT...


Speaking as a former programmer, and someone who's given it a bit of thought over the past five years or so, I'm wondering if a really competent hacker has decided to teach people a lesson about electronic voting machines in a way they can't fail to understand.

I've myself thought that hacking a few million votes on election day 2008 to swing the vote ridiculously one way --- say having Utah vote 75% democratic --- would finally make the TV networks and their telegenic clone anchors awaken in dull surprise to the fact that EVS's are designed to alter elections undetectably --- unless someone pranks the system after the serious cheaters are done with their original undetectable alterations.

Might be worth life in prison. Just one shot.


-=- Comments on this item are now closed. -=-


VotersUnite.org's Daily Voting News 'Daily Voting News'
For December 04, 2008

by John Gideon

The Help America Vote Act of 2002 (HAVA) was signed into law in Oct. 2002. Amongst other things HAVA required the formation of the Election Assistance Commission (EAC) and provided some mandates, in Title III of the law, for federal elections including some standards for voting systems. Those standards include, but are not limited to, accessibility for voters with disabilities and accuracy in the vote count. Testing by experts in accessibility has shown that none of the Direct Recording Electronic (DRE, usually touch-screen) voting systems presently in use meet the requirements for accessibility for disabled voters. Failures in testing and vote counting in real elections have also proven that, at times, the voting systems presently being used across the country do not meet the federally mandated requirements for accuracy.

So what guidance has been provided by the EAC to the states with regards to Title III? Well, actually none. In fact even though voting systems presently in use do not meet federal law the EAC is just now getting around to issuing guidance to state and local election officials and, according to the draft of the plan ‘featured’ below, it is going to take another two years before the EAC can complete the guidance.

Why can’t they just tell the vendors and the states that the law is clear and, if they fail to follow that law, violations will be referred to the DoJ? The fact that the vendors misrepresent their products as being accessible is a clear violation of the law. It is time they are held responsible and it doesn’t take two years of studying Title III of HAVA to make that clear....

Click for links to all of today's notable voting news headlines...

Support The BRAD BLOG
Please visit our advertisers




Spend your advertising dollars wisely! And support the good guys at the same time! or Advertise with the good guys! We're it!



Fight the H8 in Your State











OTHER SITES
Groomsmen Gifts - Pub signs can be personalized for a unique gift for your wedding party.

Support The BRAD BLOG
Please visit our advertisers
Brad Friedman's
The BRAD BLOG



Go to front page...

Recent Entries

Archives
Important Docs
A Few Great Blogs
Political Cartoonists
Special Coverage Pages...
Touch-Screen Vote-Flipping 2008

L.A. County "Double Bubble" Debacle

2008 New Hampshire Primary Mess